TL;DR
Get business pricing on tools and workshop supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
A Matter Alpha report says a reviewer replaced nearly all of a four-year IKEA Zigbee setup with IKEA Matter-over-Thread devices and tested them for six months. The new devices made sharing products across smart-home platforms easier and were often cheaper, but setup, speed and reliability gains were limited in the reviewer’s home.
A reviewer who replaced nearly all of a four-year IKEA Zigbee smart-home setup with IKEA Matter-over-Thread devices found greater freedom to use products across platforms, but no dramatic improvement in speed or reliability after six months. The Matter Alpha report says the new devices were often cheaper, while setup and connectivity problems persisted in the reviewer’s home.
The reviewer says the new lineup covers familiar products such as bulbs, sensors and remote controls. In the models compared, the Matter replacements often cost about 30% to 50% less than their Zigbee predecessors while offering comparable basic features. That price difference could add up for people equipping several rooms, though it does not make the newer products a clear performance upgrade.
Connectivity improved after the reviewer moved the new devices onto a shared Thread network: coverage and connection consistency were better, and devices seemed less likely to drop offline. The report describes the gain as modest. Remotes were not noticeably faster than the Zigbee versions, and response times sometimes felt slower as more Matter devices joined the network. The reviewer also says sensors such as the MYGGSPRAY motion sensor generally worked well.
Pairing remained a weakness. The reviewer estimates that about 30% of Zigbee pairing attempts succeeded on the first try. Early Matter firmware raised that personal estimate to about 50%, but still left many devices needing another attempt or a reset. Matter setup also required scanning a QR code and using an Apple or Google commissioning flow, adding steps beyond discovery in IKEA Home smart. Later firmware made the devices stable enough for daily use, but the report says setup still needs work.
Cross-Platform Control Is the Gain
The clearest change in the report is interoperability after setup, rather than a faster or more reliable connection. The reviewer says the same IKEA devices can be used with IKEA Home smart, Apple Home and Home Assistant. A button can retain IKEA’s familiar pairing and binding experience while also triggering automations in another system.
That flexibility matters for households that use more than one smart-home platform or expect their setup to change over time. The reviewer says commands can work locally rather than relying on a cloud service to pass them between platforms. Zigbee devices can also connect to third-party systems, especially through a capable hub or coordinator; the report’s distinction is that Matter makes sharing across supported platforms a more standard part of the experience. The account is one person’s test, not a controlled comparison across homes, routers or platform combinations.
Lower prices make the new range more appealing for new purchases, but the report identifies trade-offs in design. Some newer devices are bulkier because they use AAA batteries, and the reviewer found the build less refined on some models. The ALPSTUGA air-quality monitor, for example, has a simpler dot-style display than the older VINDSTYRKA’s LCD. The reviewer valued the lower price but said the newer design shows less information at a glance.
Products Worth Considering
EGO Power+ 9‑Gallon Wet/Dry Shop Vacuum with Remote Control (WDV0900) – Battery Not Included
EGO Power+ LB8803-2 Cordless Leaf Blower, 880 CFM, with Two 4.0Ah Batteries
DEWALT 18-Inch Scroll Saw with Variable Speed
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Four Years of Zigbee
The report compares IKEA’s newer Matter-over-Thread range with the reviewer’s previous four years using IKEA Zigbee products. In that earlier setup, the reviewer experienced difficult pairing and devices that sometimes disappeared from the network. Adding mains-powered Zigbee devices intended to repeat the signal, including a TRÅDFRI plug and repeater, did not reliably resolve those dropouts.
The reviewer’s home also has a crowded 2.4 GHz environment, which may shape the results. The report notes that a command can pass through several parts of a system—the device, Thread mesh, border router, Matter controller and automation—before an action occurs. This makes it difficult to attribute every delay or disconnection to the wireless protocol alone. The report’s conclusions describe this specific home and setup; it does not establish how every IKEA Matter product performs for other users.
The reviewer also misses some older physical controls, including the SYMFONISK remotes used with Sonos systems, which the report describes as compact and immediate to use. That comparison underscores that replacing a protocol does not necessarily preserve every product feature or form factor a household values.
“I cannot say the new ones are dramatically faster or more reliable.”
— Matter Alpha reviewer
Results Depend on the Home
The report does not establish whether other households will see the same connectivity or pairing results. Its findings are based on one reviewer’s home, where the 2.4 GHz environment is crowded, and the source does not provide controlled testing across different routers, Thread border routers or Matter controllers. The reviewer also says early and later firmware behaved differently, so performance may vary with software versions.
The source does not specify the prices or exact models for every comparison, nor does it provide a broader sample to verify the estimated first-attempt pairing rates. It also does not quantify response times or dropouts. The claimed 30% to 50% price reductions apply to the models the reviewer compared, not necessarily the entire product range or every market.
Keep Working Devices in Place
The reviewer’s practical advice is not to rush to replace a functioning IKEA Zigbee setup. For existing owners, the report suggests weighing the value of broader platform support and potentially lower prices against the effort of replacing devices and the possibility that setup or response-time frustrations will remain. For new purchases, the cheaper Matter models may be worth comparing, but the report does not treat them as a guaranteed reliability upgrade.
The source gives no date for a future firmware release or other product milestone. Further changes in firmware, platform support and the available product range could alter the experience, but the report does not say when those developments might occur. Readers considering a switch would need to check compatibility with their chosen controller and the specific device features they rely on.
Key Questions
Did Matter make IKEA devices faster?
Not clearly in the reviewer’s test. The Matter remotes were not noticeably faster than the Zigbee ones, and response sometimes felt slower as more Matter devices shared the network.
Were the Matter devices more reliable?
The reviewer saw better Thread coverage and more consistent connections, with fewer apparent dropouts. The improvement was described as modest, and the report does not establish that other homes will see the same result.
What was the main benefit of switching?
The strongest benefit was the ability to use the same IKEA devices across IKEA Home smart, Apple Home and Home Assistant, including combining controls and automations across platforms.
Were IKEA Matter devices cheaper?
In the models the reviewer compared, the Matter replacements were often about 30% to 50% cheaper than the Zigbee predecessors. The source does not establish that this applies to every product or market.
Should current IKEA Zigbee owners replace their devices?
The reviewer advises against rushing to replace a working Zigbee setup. Matter may be more useful for people who want broader platform support or are buying devices for the first time, but the report found no dramatic performance gain.
Source: matteralpha.com
